What Wood is Best for a Cutting Board? A Complete Guide to Choosing Your Kitchen Essential

Table of Contents

1. What Makes a Good Wood for Cutting Boards?

2. Best Woods for Cutting Boards: Maple, Walnut, Cherry, and More

3. Woods to Avoid for Cutting Boards

4. End Grain vs. Edge Grain Cutting Boards

5. Cutting Board Maintenance: Oiling, Cleaning, and Longevity

6. Which Wood Cutting Board is Right for You?

7. Conclusion

What Makes a Good Wood for Cutting Boards?

When you're choosing a cutting board, it's not just about picking the prettiest piece of wood in the store. There's actual science behind what makes certain woods better for cutting surfaces than others. Let's break down the key factors that separate the great cutting board woods from the not-so-great options.

First and foremost, we need to talk about hardwood vs. softwood. This isn't just about how hard the wood feels—it's a botanical classification. Hardwoods come from deciduous trees that lose their leaves annually, while softwoods come from coniferous trees that stay green year-round. For cutting boards, you always want hardwoods. Why? They have a tighter cellular structure that makes them more durable and less prone to absorbing moisture and bacteria.

The Janka hardness scale is your best friend when evaluating wood for cutting boards. This measures the resistance of wood to denting and wear. The sweet spot for cutting boards is between 900-1500 pounds-force. Softer than this, and your board will show cuts and scars too easily. Harder than this, and you'll be dulling your knives at an alarming rate.

Grain structure is another critical factor. Closed-grain woods (like maple and cherry) have tiny, tight pores that don't allow food particles and moisture to penetrate easily. Open-grain woods (like oak) have larger pores that can trap food and bacteria, making them less sanitary choices for cutting boards.

Food safety should be your top priority. Some woods contain natural toxins or extractives that can leach into food. Always stick to woods that are known to be food-safe. Maple, walnut, and cherry are all excellent choices that have been used for food preparation for centuries.

Lastly, consider maintenance requirements. Some woods need more frequent oiling than others to maintain their protective barrier. Walnut and cherry, for instance, require more frequent oiling due to their slightly more open pore structure compared to maple's tight grain.

Interested in having your cutting board customized? Consider hiring a professional to burn in personalized names or designs into you favorite board!

Best Woods for Cutting Boards: Maple, Walnut, Cherry, and More

Now that we know what to look for in a cutting board wood, let's explore the most popular options and what makes each of them special.

Maple: The Gold Standard

Maple is often considered the gold standard for cutting boards, and for good reason. With a Janka hardness rating of 1450, it hits that sweet spot between being durable enough to withstand years of chopping while still being gentle on your knife edges.

Pros:

• Tight, closed-grain structure that resists moisture and bacterial absorption

• Natural antimicrobial properties

• Light color shows when cleaning is needed

• Durable enough for heavy daily use

• Readily available and sustainably harvested (look for FSC certification)

Cons:

• Light color can show stains more easily than darker woods

• Requires regular oiling to maintain its protective barrier

• Can be heavier than other options

Maple is the wood you'll most often see in professional kitchens, and it's an excellent choice for home cooks too.

Walnut: The Elegant Workhorse

Walnut offers a beautiful dark chocolate color that makes it a stunning addition to any kitchen. With a Janka rating of 1010, it's slightly softer than maple but still plenty durable for regular use.

Pros:

• Rich, dark color hides stains well

• Naturally contains compounds that inhibit bacterial growth

• Softer than maple, making it even gentler on knife edges

• Beautiful grain patterns make it attractive for serving

Cons:

• More expensive than maple

• Slightly more porous than maple, requiring more frequent oiling

• Dark color can make it harder to see when cleaning is needed

Walnut is perfect for those who want both functionality and beauty in their cutting board.

Cherry: The Beautiful Aging Wood

Cherry wood has a beautiful reddish-brown color that deepens with age and exposure to light. With a Janka rating of 995, it's on the softer end of the ideal spectrum but still makes an excellent cutting surface.

Pros:

• Develops a rich patina over time

• Gentle on knife edges

• Contains natural antimicrobial compounds

• Beautiful appearance makes it great for serving

Cons:

• Softer than maple or walnut, so it may show knife marks more easily

• Requires more frequent oiling to maintain its protective barrier

• Can be more expensive than maple

Cherry is ideal for those who appreciate a cutting board that gains character with time and use.

Teak: The Durable Outdoor Option

Teak is known for its high natural oil content and water resistance, which makes it popular for outdoor furniture. But how does it fare as a cutting board?

Pros:

• Extremely water-resistant due to high natural oil content

• Very durable with a Janka rating of 1155

• Natural oils provide some protection without frequent oiling

Cons:

• High silica content can dull knives faster than other woods

• Natural oils can cause allergic reactions in some people

• Often harvested unsustainably unless certified

While teak is durable and water-resistant, its knife-dulling properties make it less ideal for cutting boards than other options.

Acacia: The Affordable Alternative

Acacia has become popular in recent years as a more affordable hardwood option for cutting boards and other kitchen items.

Pros:

• Hard and durable (Janka rating varies by species from 1100-1750)

• Natural water resistance

• Often more affordable than domestic hardwoods

• Attractive grain patterns

Cons:

• Quality can vary widely depending on source

• Often imported from countries with less stringent forestry regulations

• Some species can be overly hard and tough on knives

If choosing acacia, look for boards from reputable manufacturers who use sustainable harvesting practices.

Comparison of Popular Cutting Board Woods

Wood Type	Janka Hardness	Grain Structure	Maintenance Needs	Best For
Maple	1450	Closed	Moderate	Heavy daily use, professional kitchens
Walnut	1010	Semi-closed	Moderate to High	Home kitchens, presentation
Cherry	995	Semi-closed	High	Light to medium use, serving
Teak	1155	Open	Low	High-moisture environments
Acacia	1100-1750	Varies	Moderate	Budget-conscious shoppers

Woods to Avoid for Cutting Boards

Not all woods are created equal when it comes to food safety and functionality. Here are some types of wood you should avoid for cutting boards:

Open-grain woods like oak - While oak is a hardwood, it has large, open pores that can trap food particles and bacteria. This makes it difficult to clean thoroughly and less sanitary than closed-grain alternatives.

Softwoods like pine or cedar - These woods are too soft for cutting boards. They dent and scratch easily, creating places for bacteria to hide. They also contain more resins that can transfer flavors to food or cause allergic reactions.

Toxic woods - Some woods contain natural toxins that can leach into food. Avoid woods like yew, poison oak, poison walnut, or any wood that's known to be toxic.

Treated woods - Never use wood that's been treated with chemicals, stains, or finishes that aren't food-safe. This includes pressure-treated wood, which contains arsenic and other harmful chemicals.

Exotic woods with unknown properties - While some exotic woods are beautiful, many haven't been tested for food safety. Some, like purpleheart, can cause allergic reactions in sensitive individuals.

Composite woods - Avoid cutting boards made from particleboard, MDF, or other composite materials. These often contain formaldehyde-based adhesives that can leach into food.

When in doubt, stick with known food-safe hardwoods like maple, walnut, and cherry that have a long history of use in food preparation.

End Grain vs. Edge Grain Cutting Boards

Once you've chosen the type of wood for your cutting board, you'll face another important decision: end grain or edge grain? Understanding the difference can help you choose the right board for your needs.

What's the Difference?

Edge grain boards (also called side grain) are made by placing long strips of wood on their sides and gluing them together so the long grain is facing upward. This creates the familiar striped pattern that most people associate with wooden cutting boards.

End grain boards are made by cutting those same strips into smaller blocks and turning them so the end grain is facing upward. These are then glued together to create a checkerboard pattern.

Why Does It Matter?

The difference isn't just aesthetic—it significantly affects how the board performs and how it treats your knives.

End grain boards are gentler on knife edges. When you cut on end grain, the knife blade slips between the wood fibers, which then close back up after the cut. This "self-healing" property means the board shows fewer cut marks over time and keeps your knives sharper longer.

Edge grain boards are more affordable and require less maintenance. Since you're cutting across the wood fibers rather than between them, edge grain boards tend to show cut marks more obviously. However, they're still much better for your knives than plastic, glass, or bamboo boards.

Which Should You Choose?

Choose end grain if:

• You're serious about cooking and want the best performance

• You have expensive knives that you want to keep sharp

• You don't mind more frequent oiling and maintenance

• Budget isn't your primary concern

Choose edge grain if:

• You're looking for a more budget-friendly option

• You want a board that requires less maintenance

• You'll be using the board for serving as well as cutting

• You're not ready to commit to the high maintenance of an end grain board

Both types of boards have their place in the kitchen, and many serious cooks eventually end up with both—using end grain for heavy chopping and edge grain for lighter tasks and serving.

Cutting Board Maintenance: Oiling, Cleaning, and Longevity

A high-quality wood cutting board can last for decades—if you care for it properly. Here's everything you need to know about maintaining your investment.

Cleaning Your Cutting Board

Do:

• Wash with mild soap and warm water after each use

• Scrub with a soft brush or sponge to remove food particles

• Dry thoroughly with a clean towel immediately after washing

• Stand upright or on its feet to air dry completely before storing

Don't:

• Never soak in water or put in the dishwasher

• Don't use harsh detergents or bleach solutions

• Avoid placing near heat sources which can cause warping or cracking

For deep cleaning and deodorizing, use a paste of coarse salt and lemon juice. Sprinkle the board with salt, then use a halved lemon to scrub the surface. Let it sit for 5-10 minutes before rinsing and drying thoroughly.

Oiling and Waxing

Regular oiling is essential for keeping your wood cutting board in good condition. Oil creates a protective barrier that prevents moisture absorption and keeps the wood from drying out and cracking.

How to oil your cutting board:

1. Clean and dry the board thoroughly

2. Apply food-grade mineral oil generously to all surfaces

3. Let the oil soak in for several hours or overnight

4. Wipe off any excess oil

5. For extra protection, follow with a board wax or cream

How often should you oil?

• New boards: every couple of days for the first week, then weekly for a month

• Established boards: monthly, or whenever the wood looks dry

• To test if your board needs oiling, sprinkle a few water drops on the surface. If they bead up, you're good. If they soak in, it's time to oil

What to use:

• Food-grade mineral oil is the standard recommendation

• Avoid vegetable oils (olive, coconut, etc.) as they can turn rancid

• Specialty board oils and waxes are available and often contain beeswax for added protection

Repairing Damage

Even with proper care, your cutting board may eventually show signs of wear. Deep cuts, stains, and warping can often be repaired.

For deep cuts and stains, sanding can restore the surface. Start with coarse grit sandpaper (80-100) to remove deep damage, then progress to finer grits (150-220) to smooth the surface. Always sand with the grain of the wood.

After sanding, clean thoroughly to remove all dust, then oil generously to restore the protective barrier.

If your board develops mildew (black spots), it may be time to replace it. While sanding can sometimes remove surface mildew, it's difficult to eliminate completely once it's penetrated the wood.

Storage Tips

• Store boards upright in a dry, well-ventilated area

• Avoid storing in damp areas where mold and mildew can develop

• Don't store near heat sources like ovens or radiators

• If storing for long periods, make sure the board is thoroughly clean and oiled

With proper care, a quality wood cutting board can become a family heirloom that lasts for generations.

Which Wood Cutting Board is Right for You?

Now that we've explored all the options, how do you choose the right cutting board for your needs? Here's a quick guide based on different cooking styles and needs.

For the serious home chef:
If you cook daily and value your knives, invest in an end grain board made of maple or walnut. The initial investment will pay off in years of reliable service and knife protection.

For the occasional cook:
An edge grain board made of maple or acacia offers a great balance of performance and affordability. It will be easier to maintain while still protecting your knives better than plastic or glass.

For the entertainer:
Consider a beautiful walnut or cherry board that can double as a serving platter. The rich colors and grain patterns make for stunning presentation when serving cheese, charcuterie, or appetizers.

For small kitchens:
Look for a smaller board (around 12x18 inches) that's easy to handle and store. Many manufacturers offer boards with juice grooves and handles for added functionality in limited spaces.

For families with young children:
Consider having multiple boards in different colors or styles for different tasks. This makes it easy to enforce food safety practices like using separate boards for raw meats and vegetables.

For those with sustainability concerns:
Look for boards made from domestically sourced woods with FSC certification. Maple from the northeastern US or walnut from the Midwest are excellent choices that support sustainable forestry practices.

No matter which board you choose, remember that proper care is essential for longevity. Factor in the maintenance requirements when making your decision—if you're not willing to oil regularly, you might be better served with a high-quality plastic board for raw proteins and a wood board for everything else.

Conclusion

Choosing the right wood for your cutting board is about balancing several factors: hardness, grain structure, maintenance requirements, and of course, budget. While maple remains the gold standard for its perfect balance of durability and knife-friendliness, walnut and cherry offer beautiful alternatives with their own unique properties.

Remember that end grain boards, while more expensive and demanding more maintenance, provide the best surface for your knives. Edge grain boards offer a more affordable and lower-maintenance option that's still far superior to plastic, glass, or bamboo.

Whichever board you choose, commit to proper care and maintenance. Regular cleaning, drying, and oiling will ensure your cutting board remains a trusted kitchen companion for years to come. A well-chosen and well-maintained wood cutting board isn't just a kitchen tool—it's an investment in your culinary journey that can even become a family heirloom passed down through generations. Consider having yours professionally customized!

Happy chopping!

Related Articles — Check out these guides to all things woodworking!

Top 10 Wood for Custom Wood Signs

Preventing Wood Warping and Swelling

A Deep Dive Into the Art of Woodburning